Featuring the finest pet foods available, from traditional dry and canned, to the latest grain-free diets, as well as a varied selection of raw and cooked frozen foods. We strive to offer you the widest variety of nutritional options for your pets. We carry everything you need for cats, dogs, small animals, birds, reptiles, and fish. Come see us for the broadest line of fresh frozen raw diets in the region! We are very proud of our line up of dog and cat foods, offering products from over two-dozen manufacturers of the finest natural and holistic foods available.

Update Share

About Us Report

At Pets Pets Pets we strive to partner with you providing your pets with the finest products available to help guarantee them a happy and healthy life.

Services Report

Our product line strives to offer everything a loving caregiver needs and wants for their pets. Since we do not sell pets we are able to focus our attention on maintaining an inventory that reflects our caring philosophy and best serves our customers. We are very proud of our line up of dog and cat foods, offering products from over two-dozen manufacturers of the finest natural and holistic foods available. Our selection includes both kibbled and canned foods as well as several freeze-dried foods and no less than four brands of raw frozen diets.

Raw Foods Report

At Pets Pets Pets we do believe that feeding raw diets provides your dogs and cats with the most nutritional and healthiest diets available today. Please take some time and avail yourself of this information and feel free to contact us at anytime for more information on Raw Feeding or the products we carry and come back often as I hope to continually add more content to the page.

Dog Food & Supplies Report

Here at Pets Pets Pets, our team is dedicated to the health of dogs. We proudly offer a selection of dog items which help you to keep their tail wagging. Regardless if your dog is a young puppy or a senior dog, our helpful team is glad to help you find the most suitable items. Come to check out our amazing inventory of dog products at our pet retail store in Califon, NJ.

Sussudio York

Apr 17, 2022

Report

Very friendly and helpful owners and staff. Super knowledgeable and ready to answer any questions you have, I especially love the home town feel you get from interacting with them!

E. Murphy

Mar 21, 2022

Report

I recently went to Pets Pets Pets for dog treats. They had a great selection of chews and had an excellent sale going on. I was able to stock up and buy some new options for my dog. The store sponsors a monthly pet adoption. Best of all the owners were very helpful, friendly & accommodating! Love to supporting local businesses.

Lisa Lee

Jan 07, 2022

Report

Have been here several times- not sure how they can tell how many times I've been a customer as I never signed up for your program. Each time either out of stock or horrible customer service. I drive further away for my pet supplies or use Amazon.

Carolyn Thow

Dec 27, 2021

Report

Love Pets Pets Pets - the owner is very knowledgeable and always going the extra mile for my pets. They have a great selection of all natural products: food, treats & care. Definitely recommend them for your pet needs.

Paraskeve Eleftheriou

Dec 13, 2021

Report

Always helpful! Always on point with what all my pets should be eating and I drive one hour for this personalized experience! Worth the trip every time Thanks again

Jennifer F.

Nov 19, 2021

Report

Over priced, dark and unwelcoming. Unless you are looking for high priced food for your pets look elsewhere. Most shelves were empty and the owners were not very welcoming either.

Devorah Grunau

Sep 10, 2021

Report

We just went to Petpetpets in Califon and it was an amazing experience! We went because our senior Yorkie has been having some behavioral issues. He is also rapidly losing is eyesight which is contributing to his overall anxiety. We wanted to try a holistic approach and the owner of the store spent a very long time explaining different options with us; did not promote anything or hard sell us. She is a source of great info and expertise. We also left with different dog food and peace of mind!

Abigail Shivers

Aug 21, 2021

Report

This store is wonderful! There is a food for every dog/cat/small animal there and lots of great treats and toys too! Great place to bring your dog to socialize. we even had a cat come in once!

Laura Heimlich

Aug 21, 2021

Report

We just moved to the neighborhood and are so happy to have met the owner of Pets Pets Pets! She is the most knowledgeable person I have ever met with regards to pet nutrition. She goes out of her way to spend time with her customers and to make sure they get what they need for their fur babies. Big box pet stores cannot ever compare. We look forward to continuing to shop at this local gem! Shop small and local!

Leone Atkinson

Apr 15, 2021

Report

Best place to go for honest advice on dog food choices. They recommended plaque off for our small dogs teeth and there teeth have never looked better! Wonderful service and very easy to shop at during the pandemic.

Marta Bambo

Apr 09, 2021

Report

Great experience at Pets pets pets! The staff is friendly and very well informed. They took the time to help with my dogs special needs. They have a great selection for all pet needs! Highly recommend!

S. Thaler

Mar 17, 2021

Report

We love this pet store! The owner, Mary, is so knowledgeable about pet nutrition! She was able to solve the stomach issues or dog had been having when our vet couldn't. Our dog loves visiting the store, and the staff truly build a personal relationship with both you and your pets. I can't praise this local little pet store enough!

John Visci

Feb 24, 2021

Report

Pets Pets Pets is a top notch establishment. Mary and her staff are always cordial and very competent in their knowledge of pet nutrition and have detailed information on the extensive array of their product selection. Pricing is very competitive making this establishment the best for all of your pet's needs.

Janine D.

Feb 05, 2020

Report

I've been going to this store since we moved here. The owner s great and super helpful -- they have a large selection of treats and toys and are willing to go the extra mile.

Abby L.

Jul 20, 2019

Report

Used to love going here and getting items for our pets. Ever since the place got a new owner, we stopped. She's incredibly rude and made fun of us while we were shopping. Such a shame. Shouldn't be saying that kind of stuff to your customers. There's better pet stores out there with nicer staff.

Heidi G.

Apr 25, 2019

Report

The owner is very friendly and helpful! We will now be using Pets Pets Pets for all of our pets needs.

Alan S.

Dec 06, 2017

Report

Great local business. Food for every type of pets. They feature foid for Raw Frozen food diets.

Eric F.

Dec 31, 2012

Report

Dependable, well-stocked, friendly, reasonably priced, and local. What more can you ask for?

Daniel H.

Dec 24, 2008

Report

Local store with good quality pet products. Has lots of "better" stuff that the major chains don't carry.